Choose the Best Waterproof Eyeliner
Customer’s Choice: the Best Rated Waterproof Eyeliners
1 users answered this survey. Please help us improve this review!
Waterproof eyeliner is a type of eyeliner that will not come off when you rub your eyes or get caught in the rain. These liners can be perfect for all-day wear and even swimming!
With so many different brands of eyeliner on the market, it can be hard to know which one is best for you. With all the new releases coming out every year, it’s difficult to figure out what is worth your money and time. That’s why we put together this guide about the best waterproof eyeliners! Makeup experts compare products from popular makeup brands like Rimmel and NYX Cosmetics to give you an unbiased opinion of what product will work best for you.
Nyx Professional Makeup Epic Ink Liner – the Editor’s choice!
With Nyx, it’s about redefining your favorite features with a budget-friendly product that’s amazingly versatile and long-lasting.
With Nyx Professional Makeup Epic Ink Liner, your eyes will always be beautiful, on-trend, and dramatic. Its water-resistant formula is strong enough for use with heavy outwear too! From the everyday office look to the party girl glamour, you can create any kind of statement with this long-wearing precision brush.
The Nyx Epic Ink Liner is built for all-day wear, giving you the confidence to take on any task. With its twist-up applicator and great pigment color range, it’s easy to apply and create your perfect look. The waterproof formula guarantees that your eyeliner will never smudge or fade! Plus, there are 3 popular colors that whoever orders one is sure to find their new favorite shade!
Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner – the best for ease of use!
The kind of sharp that doesn’t fade as the night wears on, Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner from Stila leaves zero room for error in your eye line.
This product comes in 10 shades including black, dark brown, bronze gold shimmer, cocoa matte brown, deep gray blackberry, glittery purple, etc
This Stilla’s easy-to-use liner lasts all day and night—so you don’t have to worry about smudges, feathering, or running. It has a no-gap precision-point applicator that is durable and provides smooth lines for any occasion; perfect for the bright green cat eye or an ultra-fine single line.
Rimmel Scandaleyes Waterproof Gel Eye Liner Pencil – the best for sensitive eyes!
It offers intense color with an intense waterproof formula – never worry about touching up your line or having it smudge.
And if perfection isn’t enough, it even comes in few different finishes – brown, nude, black, extremely black, deep blue, sparkling black – so getting ready is easier than ever before!
Rimmel Scandaleyes Waterproof Gel Eye Liner Pencil is everything you need for flawless, dramatic eyes that stay gorgeous. Rich hues deliver an instant punch of color and the blendable texture creates drama with ease. Also, it can be used if you have sensitive eyes or wear contact lenses.
Rimmel Exaggerate Eye Definer – the best for smokey eyes!
Love parties and going out? This product can be good dramatic, bold looks that stand out! It’s made of smooth texture and has a fine tip which means having a perfectly precise application for those tough spots like waterline or tight lining!
You’ll be ready to go as soon as you’ve mastered this easy make-up routine thanks to the four major colors, a wide variety of line widths, and gentle formula! Start now by trying Rimmel’s Exaggerate Eye Definer!
The secret to a standout look is a perfect smokey finish. That’s why Rimmel created the Waterproof Eye Definer with intense, rich color that’s easy to wear and long-lasting wear.
Docolor Waterproof Eyeliner Pen – the best for intense black color!
This natural formula can be perfect for contact lens wearers and those who want a precise, sharp line, Docolor eyeliner withstands the harshest conditions without fading or running over time.
Say goodbye to smudging, clumping pen tips, and dull black color with Docolor waterproof eyeliner pen!
Do you need a precision, matte black cat-eye that won’t smudge? Reach for Docolor Waterproof Pen Liner. This innovative product has everything you need to create lasting eye makeup with intense color and no blurring. It’s the perfect combination of strength, simplicity, and style for any occasion.
The Buyer’s Guide
Why Should You Use Waterproof Eyeliner?
Whether you want to look your best for a special occasion or just need something that will stay in place all day, waterproof eyeliner is the way to go.
Waterproof makeup can be used in many different ways and it comes with plenty of benefits:
Waterproof makeup is long-lasting
Another good reason to use waterproof makeup is that it lasts for a very long time without fading or smudging. This type of product typically stays on until you remove the makeup completely from your face with an oil-based remover, so no touchups are necessary during the day! In fact, some people choose not to wear any other kind of foundation underneath their waterproof one because it gives such great coverage and hides imperfections well enough by itself. Also sometimes having many layers of different products can cause breakouts which aren’t something anyone wants! With this in mind using only a single layer has its benefits as well as a simple application process and less potential for irritation.
Waterproof eyeliner is easy to remove
One of the best things about waterproof eye makeup is that it’s easy to take off. This type of eyeliner comes with a smoother, more matte finish than other types which allows you to glide on easily without smudging or tugging at your delicate skin. It also dries quickly so there isn’t any waiting around for it to dry before applying additional products or opening your eyes all the way! Once set, this product stays put until you use an oil-based remover and even then some people may find they need multiple applications in order to get their entire lash line completely clean again. Since most people don’t wear waterproof mascara too often (and when they do are usually only doing so for special occasions) it’s not too much of an inconvenience to have to go through the extra step.
Waterproof makeup is ideal for sensitive skin
The last reason to use waterproof eyeliner is that it’s great for people with very delicate or sensitive skin. Since most traditional products are water-soluble, they will just wash off when you get sweaty which isn’t the case with this type of product. This doesn’t mean that your face won’t sweat at all if you wear waterproof makeup but, in general, it’s much more resistant and likely to stay on even after a workout or spending time outside in hot weather. You can also feel safe knowing your eyeshadow didn’t run down your cheeks during an intense crying session! The same can be said about using one product for both eyes makeup and foundation as well since there aren’t any harsh chemicals between your eyes and face that can lead to irritation or infections.
What type of liner is best for me:
1) Gel eyeliner
Stays on longer than liquid liner, giving you more time to work with it before it sets. It also has a very smooth and sleek finish that is great for people who prefer natural-looking makeup overdramatic lines. This type of eyeliner doesn’t smudge easily so if that’s something that bothers you then gel liners are definitely the way to go! Just keep in mind that they can be difficult to remove completely from your lid since water alone won’t do the trick.
2) Cream eyeliner
This type of eyeliner is very easy to apply because it glides on smoothly and stays put all day. Since the product comes in a pot, you will need an angled brush or liner brush for smooth application without getting any outside the lines. Cream liners are ideal for creating subtle eye looks that won’t fade throughout your day but they can also be used with other types of makeup products if desired!
Liquid eyeliners give you complete control over how thick or thin your line is which makes them great for either dramatic evening looks or more natural everyday styles. The only downside here is that they typically take longer than gel ones to dry so there’s some waiting around before moving onto additional steps such as applying mascara. They’re also not as smudge or smear-proof as gel liners and can even run if you get sweaty which is why it’s best to use this type of liner at night when there isn’t any risk of ruining your eye makeup.
Pencil liners are the most natural-looking type of eyeliner but they can still give you a nice pop for special occasions. They also come in many different colors that add some variety to your look without having to switch up eye shadow or other products. The downside to using pencil liner is that it can take some practice getting used to how hard you need to press the pencil against your lash line in order for the color to show up.
Finally, think about how easy each type of liner will actually be for you to use: some people prefer using pencils while others swear by gel liners so decide what works best with your own personal preferences and don’t be afraid to try out different types of liners until you find something that works for your specific needs.
The quality of waterproof eyeliners can differ greatly from brand to brand so it’s important to pick a high-quality product that you know will stay on all day. Some people have very oily skin and may want to use a liner with more staying power since they’ll constantly be touching their face throughout the day or wiping away sweat which causes makeup products to smudge much easier than usual!
On the other hand, people who don’t wear any type of foundation might prefer using something lighter like pencils for everyday looks since gel liners are typically thicker in consistency due to having ingredients such as beeswax added into them.
You should also consider the brand’s reputation since there are many cheap products on the market that may not provide great quality. This can be especially true when considering drugstore options as they have lower prices but might not offer many benefits over high-end brands that cost more money because of their overall better product consistency and ability to create longer-lasting makeup.
The best waterproof eyeliner formulas are typically gel or liquid. These formulas last longer than pencils, and they’re also easier to apply with precision. You can get the most accurate lines when you use a smooth formula with such components as carnauba wax  and beeswax. These ingredients help the eyeliner glide smoothly across your skin without tugging or pulling, so you can keep it on all day long.
Is black eyeliner the only option? Absolutely not! Eyeliners come in many different colors that work for an endless amount of looks like brown, white, pink, green, purple, etc. You may be surprised by how much fun adding some extra color to your eyeshadow routine could be!
Don’t forget about shimmery eyeliner either since those are especially great for creating dramatic evening makeup styles. The sky really is the limit with all these choices so just remember to have fun and don’t stress if you make a mistake.
Ease of Application
Some people love using gel liner because it is easy to control and apply. A thin, angled brush can create the most precise line with little effort. Some eyeliners are waterproof but not smudge-proof or budge-proof. If you rub your eyes, a lot this will make them come off faster than other types of makeup.
How do you know which brand will work best for your skin type? Are there specific brands to avoid when shopping around? The answer is not always the same. It depends on what side of things you are looking at, and that can change depending on who’s doing the review or test in question. Most makeup experts recommend going with a highly reputable company like Nyx Cosmetics, Blinc Cosmetics, Clinique, Kryolan Cosmetics, Smashbox, Urban Decay, Maybelline, Revlon, Covergirl, L’Oreal.
The 100% waterproof eyeliners of the lower end of the price range are more likely to not be smudge-proof. Even if they do claim that you should expect some smudging and color transfer with these budget-friendly options. A good thing about them is that almost all can be found in drugstores or online for a reasonable price. The average price is about $20-$50.
Before choosing an eyeliner consider your own needs first: is this going onto my face (waterproof) or onto my eyes (non-waterproof)? How long do you need it to last? Do you want a pencil, gel, or liquid eyeliner? What color is best for your complexion and hair color?
How to apply a waterproof eyeliner:
- First, remove any previous makeup and clean your face. You can use a facial cleanser or micellar water for this job;
- Next, apply primer to the eyelids before you go in with your liner. This is essential because it makes your color appear more vivid and keeps it from smudging throughout the day;
- Now that you’ve got your primer on (and thoroughly dried), let’s add some product! Most people prefer using pencils over liquids but there are still lots of good options when picking out a fine tip marker;
- Another option is a gel eyeliner, which provides intense color and smooth application. You can apply it with a brush or by dipping the wand directly into the pot! Gels are also good for creating winged liners because they’re super opaque once you get them going on your lid;
- The liquid is definitely the most versatile as you can make several types of lines with it (think thick or thin). It’s also easy to do some detailed work on your eyes like creating a wing;
- Try choosing liners in different materials – pencils are great for getting sharp wings while gels stay put all day long. The liquid will create a subtle line that won’t smudge easily so they’re perfect if you need something more low-key throughout the day;
- Apply the thinnest liner first before going over your look with a thicker product to keep things looking precise and clean cut. For extra drama, you can always go over your liner with a dark shadow to create an even bolder effect;
- For the most dramatic looks, consider applying false lashes or lash extensions to really show off that lash line;
Do You Need Something Special To Remove A Waterproof Eyeliner?
Waterproof eyeliners are often used to create dramatic eye makeup looks. However, they can also be tricky to remove without the proper tools. Waterproof products require special removers that dissolve waterproof materials like oils and waxes much faster than regular makeups do.
The best way to avoid removing your gorgeous look is by using a gentle oil-based cleanser or cleansing oil every night before bedtime. Remember not to tug at sensitive skin during this process as you may cause irritation and damage!
How to remove a waterproof eyeliner:
- Apply the oil cleanser to your face and wait for it to absorb;
- Gently wipe off the makeup with dry cotton pads or tissue paper. If you’re wearing a lot of waterproof eyeliner, try soaking the cotton pad first in water before wiping away your makeup;
- Wash your face after removing all traces of waterproof eyeliners;
- Apply a soothing moisturizing cream to your face;
- Finish with sunscreen every morning before you leave the house;
Comparison of Waterproof Eyeliners
When it comes to choosing a waterproof eyeliner, there are several important factors to consider. To help you make an informed decision, we have compared various indicators of different waterproof eyeliners in the table below.
|Water Resistance||Indicates the degree of waterproofness. Higher resistance ensures the eyeliner stays intact even in water.|
|Longevity||Refers to how long the eyeliner lasts without smudging or fading.|
|Pigmentation||Indicates the intensity and opacity of the eyeliner color.|
|Applicator Type||Describes the type of applicator, such as brush, felt-tip, or pencil, which can affect precision and ease of use.|
|Drying Time||Specifies how quickly the eyeliner dries after application.|
|Smudge-proof||Indicates whether the eyeliner resists smudging, especially when touched or rubbed.|
|Ease of Removal||Describes how easily the eyeliner can be removed without excessive rubbing or irritation.|
|Hypoallergenic||Specifies whether the eyeliner is formulated to minimize the risk of causing allergic reactions.|
This table provides an overview of the essential indicators to consider when choosing a waterproof eyeliner. Each indicator plays a crucial role in determining the performance and suitability of the product for your needs. By evaluating these factors, you can make a more informed decision and find the perfect waterproof eyeliner for your preferences and requirements.
What is a good eyeliner that stays on all day?
The best eyeliners are water-resistant and long-lasting. They don’t smudge or smear, so they can last all day without wearing off even when you get sweaty from the weather or exercise.
Is there a true waterproof eyeliner?
There is no eyeliner that never comes off. For example, tattooing your eyes will not make them waterproof! However, there are some great products out there for people with oily skin or watery eyes. Most of the time it’s a trade-off between smudge-proof and long-lasting color – if you want longer-lasting colors then something has to give in terms of staying power.
What eyeliners are not waterproof?
Do you know that not all eyeliners are waterproof? It is possible to find some types of eyeliners that can be used for a long time, but they will never last if there is any kind of water. This type of product usually fades away when it meets moisture or sweat and this happens because the ingredient responsible for making them smudge-free does not allow them to be protected from humidity.
Should you use waterproof eyeliner?
Waterproof eyeliners are great for those who work out, swim a lot and/or cry often. It also helps if you have oily lids or tears that drip down your face throughout the day. If you want to look flawless all day long – this is the type of product to use!
Can you swim with waterproof eyeliner?
Although some waterproof treatments are resistant to total water immersion, such as swimming (super smudge-proof), they also include more powerful chemicals to make it happen .
Is waterproof eyeliner bad for your eyes?
Waterproof eyeliners are not necessarily bad for your eyes. If you use a high-quality product and apply it the right way, they won’t feel uncomfortable on your delicate skin or cause any problems with vision. The choice of waterproof eyeliner is entirely up to personal preference. Some people like them because they stay put all day long without smudging while others prefer easy-to-remove products instead.
Does waterproof eyeliner smudge?
No, waterproof eyeliner does not smudge. That makes it different from the regular one that you find at your local drug store or department store.
Is waterproof eyeliner hard to get off?
You can find waterproof eyeliners in both liquid and pencil forms. The best way to get this type of product off your skin is by using a good eye makeup remover that will break down the chemicals used to create it.
Many people have sensitive eyes, so you may want to test out how well an eye makeup remover works on yourself before buying a large bottle or making a purchase online.
There are also some oil-based removers that will break down waterproof makeup. A good example of this is coconut oil, which is used by many people to remove their eye shadow and eyeliners before bed each night or after a long day at work.
If you prefer not to use an oily product on your skin, however, there are synthetic oils available in most drugstores as well as natural ones like olive oil for those who want to avoid petroleum-based chemicals.
What gets waterproof eyeliner off?
Waterproof eyeliners can be difficult to remove. Some of the most effective methods for removing waterproof makeup include using micellar water, makeup wipes, oil-based makeup removers, or even coconut oil. However, there are also some DIY remedies you can use at home! For example, sometimes putting on a hot towel and letting it sit on your eyes for just 5 minutes is enough to loosen up the formula.
You could also try making your own homemade cleansing milk with ingredients like:
- cucumbers (which act as natural astringents);
- lemon juice (a great source of vitamin C);
- aloe vera (helps soothe skin irritation);
- yogurt (full of nutrients that help nourish dry skin);
- honey (nourishes dehydrated skin);
Does micellar water remove waterproof eyeliner?
Micellar water is a mild cleanser that may also be used to remove mascara, including the waterproof variety. It can also be used on your face and lips, in addition to removing waterproof mascara. Not only is it gentle enough for sensitive skin, it’s also suitable for all types of skin, especially acne-prone complexions and sensitive skin .
How do you get eyeliner off without makeup wipes?
There are a few different ways to do this. The easiest way is with an oil-based makeup removal product like coconut or almond oil, jojoba oil, olive oil, aloe vera gel, and even baby wipes can work in a pinch! You could also use simple petroleum jelly (Vaseline) which works well for waterproof mascara too.
If you want something that’s specifically designed as an eye makeup remover, try Klorane Gentle Dry Eye Makeup Removing Lotion. It uses soothing plant extracts instead of harsh chemicals but it does contain mineral oils so if your eyes are sensitive definitely patch test first before going all out on the rest of your face.
Another option is micellar water – e.g. Garnier’s Micellar Cleansing Water for Delicate Eyes with its ultra-gentle formula is a great choice for those who prefer non-oily methods.
Can you use baby oil to take makeup off?
Yes, you can. But first, take a cotton ball and put some baby oil on it. Then gently dab the cotton ball with your eyes closed to remove makeup from your eyeliner or mascara. Baby oil works well because it doesn’t leave an oily residue which is common in most makeup removers that include oils such as coconut oil or almond oil.
Should you put eyeliner on the bottom lid?
The eyeliner on the bottom lid is a look that not everyone can pull off. In fact, most people do it wrong and find themselves looking like they have been in some sort of accident or have an illness where their eyes are blacked out from being swollen shut – neither one looks good.
If you feel like trying something new then go for it but make sure to follow these steps:
- Blend your liner well. A thin line only makes the mistake seem more obvious so blend your liner with either a sponge tip applicator (like this) or even better, use a pencil brush;
- Place your liner at the waterline and then smudge it. The pencil brush does a great job of pushing the eyeliner against the lash line, while also giving you control over how much product is used.
- Apply your liner on the bottom lid. If you are still unsure, start by lining just under the lash line and then work your way towards to outer corner;
With those three easy steps, not only will it make blending easier but also stop any harsh lines from occurring as well as give a softer look overall.
How do you stop your eyeliner and mascara from running under your eyes?
- Use a good eye primer for long-lasting makeup results. In that way, you can save yourself from having to touch up your eyes throughout the day because it will keep looking fresh and fabulous all day! Eye primers are specially formulated with ingredients like silicone or dimethicone  that provide an oil-free surface so eyeliner and mascara won’t smudge or run easily. They also absorb excess oils on the lids creating a smooth base for foundation application while locking in moisture between layers of makeup. This creates better adhesion, longer wear time while providing more color depth and intensity when applying liquid eye shadows too! You just have to use this product before applying your other cosmetics products – then wait until they dry out completely before adding another layer over it;
- Apply product in the lash line and not on the lid itself to prevent smudging! Using a precise eyeliner brush, apply your liner close to lashes for an even application without any tugging or skipping;
- If using a pencil, then you have to sharpen it often so that the tip is always sharp. This will help produce an even line without any gaps or smudging! It’s best if you use one with a thinner angled head for more control over your lines and angles as well;
- Do not apply the liner from the lash line all the way up towards the eyebrows because this can make eyes look smaller instead of larger which is what everyone wants to achieve in most cases. Instead, you should stop at about halfway between lashes and brows – extending beyond the upper lid only by a centimeter but no further than that! If going out on date night or going somewhere fancy where makeup needs to be perfect just extend the line slightly upward so that it does not look too overdone;
What are the benefits of using waterproof eyeliners?
Waterproof eyeliners offer several benefits, including long-lasting wear, smudge-proof application, and the ability to withstand water, sweat, and humidity. They are ideal for activities such as swimming, exercising, or when you need your eyeliner to stay put throughout the day.
Do waterproof eyeliners work for oily skin?
Yes, waterproof eyeliners are particularly suitable for individuals with oily skin. They are designed to adhere to the skin and resist the natural oils produced by the skin, making them less likely to smudge or fade throughout the day.
Can I use waterproof eyeliner on my waterline?
Yes, you can use waterproof eyeliner on your waterline. However, it is essential to choose a formula that is specifically designed for this purpose and labeled as safe for use on the waterline. Always ensure that the eyeliner is applied carefully and avoid getting it directly in your eyes.
Are waterproof eyeliners difficult to remove?
Waterproof eyeliners can be more challenging to remove than regular eyeliners. However, with the right makeup remover, such as an oil-based cleanser or a dual-phase makeup remover, you can effectively remove waterproof eyeliner without excessive rubbing or tugging.
Can I use waterproof eyeliner if I have sensitive eyes?
If you have sensitive eyes, it is advisable to proceed with caution when using waterproof eyeliners. Some formulas may contain ingredients that could potentially irritate sensitive eyes. Look for hypoallergenic or ophthalmologist-tested options specifically formulated for sensitive eyes to minimize the risk of irritation.
Do waterproof eyeliners come in different colors?
Yes, waterproof eyeliners are available in a wide range of colors. From classic black and brown to vibrant blues, greens, and purples, you can find waterproof eyeliners in various shades to suit your preferences and create different eye makeup looks.
Can I create different eyeliner styles with waterproof eyeliners?
Absolutely! Waterproof eyeliners can be used to create a variety of eyeliner styles, including winged, cat-eye, or smoky looks. Their long-lasting and smudge-proof properties make them ideal for achieving precise and defined lines or more dramatic effects.
Can I use waterproof eyeliner if I wear contact lenses?
Yes, you can use waterproof eyeliner if you wear contact lenses. However, it is essential to be cautious and avoid getting the eyeliner directly on the lenses. Apply the eyeliner carefully along the lash line, and if you experience any discomfort, consult with your eye care professional.
Are waterproof eyeliners safe for sensitive skin?
Waterproof eyeliners can be used on sensitive skin, but it is crucial to choose products that are specifically formulated for sensitive skin or have undergone dermatological testing. Always perform a patch test before applying the eyeliner to ensure it does not cause any adverse reactions.
How can I remove waterproof eyeliner without causing irritation?
To remove waterproof eyeliner without causing irritation, use a gentle makeup remover specifically designed for waterproof products. Apply the remover to a cotton pad or swab and hold it against the eyeliner for a few seconds to allow the product to break down. Then, gently wipe away the eyeliner, avoiding any excessive rubbing or tugging.
Useful Video: 7 Best Waterproof Eyeliners You Can Trust This Summer
This guide has given you the inside scoop on what eyeliners we think will work best for your needs. We want to make it easy on everyone by providing all of our research in one place so that no matter where you are, or how much time you have right now, finding the perfect waterproof eyeliner is as simple as following these reviews and tips! So if you’re looking to find a new waterproof liner that won’t smudge or smear, read our guide and get to shopping!