Success usually comes to those who are too busy to be looking for it.Henry David Thoreau

5 Best Waterproof Gel Eyeliners


Most recommended
Makeup Eyestudio Lasting Drama Gel
  • Maybelline New York
  • Gel
A good choice too
Cream Eyeliner, Water-Resistant Smudge-Proof
  • Brand E.l.f.
  • Color Black
  • Item Weight 0.03 Pounds
A good choice too
Neutrogena Intense Gel Eyeliner with Antioxidant
  • Brand Neutrogena
  • Color Jet Black
  • Adult
Rimmel Scandaleyes Waterproof Gel Eyeliner
  • Brand Rimmel
  • Color Black
  • Item Weight 0.01 Pounds
Mommy Makeup Waterproof Stay Put Gel
  • Mommy Makeup
  • Item Form Gel
  • Color Mischievous

Choose the Best Waterproof Gel Eyeliner

Customer’s Choice: the Best Rated Waterproof Gel Eyeliners

2 users answered this survey. Please help us improve this review!

50.00% of users selected Makeup Eyestudio Lasting Drama Gel, 0.00% selected Cream Eyeliner, Water-Resistant Smudge-Proof, 0.00% selected Neutrogena Intense Gel Eyeliner with Antioxidant, 50.00% selected Rimmel Scandaleyes Waterproof Gel Eyeliner and 0.00% selected Mommy Makeup Waterproof Stay Put Gel. Every month we analyze your answers and change our rating.

Do you love trying new makeup products, but hate when they smudge and run throughout the day? If so, you need to try a waterproof gel eyeliner! These products are designed to stay in place all day long, no matter what you are doing. In this blog post, we will discuss some of the best waterproof gel eyeliners on the market today. We will also provide tips on how to apply them correctly so that you get the most out of them.

Maybelline New York Drama Gel Eye Liner

This new eyeliner from Maybelline New York is perfect for all your dramatic needs. The clear gel formula sets instantly and delivers long-lasting color that will last until you remove it with water, soap, or another product!

This smudge-free intense pigmentation also works well as a nice base if wearing contacts so there’s no need to worry about any waterproofing agents getting into their way either – which means less hassle when putting on those sleepy false eyelashes at nighttime too 😉

  • Available in 3 colors
  • Easy to apply
  • Waterproof; even my makeup remover has a hard time getting this stuff to disappear
  • Creamy and blendable if you want to smudge it out a bit, but it isn’t going to get too far
  • Affordable
  • Hard to take off due to one of the pros listed above

e.l.f. Cream Eyeliner

Introducing a new, long-wear eyeliner that will stay on through anything! This cream formula is smudge-proof and budge-free. It’s perfect for any occasion – from school or work to date night with husband (or lover).

Create the most gorgeous makeup look ever by using this amazing product; go ultra-thin when creating an elegant daytime glance in order to achieve those delicate eyes everyone loves so much, then give them some attitude by applying thicker lines near the top lash line as well.

  • Easy, smooth application
  • Matte jet black finish
  • Stays on all-day
  • Comes with a brush

  • Easy, smooth application
  • Matte jet black finish
  • Stays on all-day
  • Comes with a brush

Neutrogena Intense Gel Eyeliner

Looking for a bold, dramatic eyeliner that won’t smudge or fade? Look no further than Neutrogena Intense Gel Eyeliner in Jet Black! This highly pigmented liner provides a solid line that will last all day and night.

The quick and easy applicator ensures an even line in just one stroke, while the Vitamin E-infused formula keeps your eyes looking healthy and vibrant. The gentle, water-resistant formula is perfect for precise application on the waterline and helps make your eyes look larger and more awake.

  • Goes on easily and the blender pad helps for cleaning and smudged looks
  • Doesn’t require heavy pressure to apply
  • Affordable
  • Available in 3 colors
  • Long-wearing

  • The tip breaks off often

Rimmel Scandaleyes Eyeliner

You need a liner that can keep up with your every move. That’s why we have Rimmel Scandalous Eye Liner on our list. Up to 24 hours of waterproof color will make sure your look lasts all day and all night.

The creamy texture is easy to apply, so you can create any look you want with ease. And the professional brush provides complete control for precise application. So go ahead – scandalize everyone with your killer eye makeup looks!

  • Comes with a brush
  • Safe ingredients
  • EWG rating of only 1
  • Vibrant color
  • Waterproof

  • Does smudge a little around eyelids after about 4 hours

Mommy Makeup Eyeliner

Introducing this all-new long-wearing gel eyeliner! This bad boy lasts all day into the night and is perfect for when you want a more lined and defined eye. Plus, it’s now paraben-free, waterproof, smudge-proof, and long-wearing. So whether you’re hitting up a party or just running errands, this liner will keep your eyes looking fierce.

This eyeliner also comes with a new formula that doesn’t dry out like other leading brands. Score! And if you’re feeling especially glamourous, be sure to use our pointed eyeliner brush (sold separately) to apply the liner

  • Available in many colors
  • Glides on easy
  • Does not break apart
  • Waterproof and lasts most all-day

  • Available in many colors
  • Glides on easy
  • Does not break apart
  • Waterproof and lasts most all-day

Buyer’s Guide

Advantages and Disadvantages of Gel Eyeliners

Gel eyeliner is a great choice if you want your eyes to look more mature and mysterious. It is also the best option for those who are looking for an easy-to-apply product that lasts long. In this part, we will discuss all the advantages and disadvantages so that you can choose the best one for your eyes.


  • Easy to apply: Applying gel eyeliner is easier than you might think. You can use a brush to apply the product to your eyes or simply dip it directly into the container and put it on without any special tools [1].
  • Lasts long: Gel eyeliner lasts much longer than other types of liner, so you don’t have to worry about it smudging or fading throughout the day.
  • Available in different colors: Gel eyeliners come in a variety of colors so you can find the perfect one for your outfit and makeup style.
  • Control thickness: Another great thing about gel eyeliners is that you can control the thickness of the line so you can create a look that suits your preferences.
  • Not tug on the skin: Unlike other products, gel eyeliners do not tug on the skin so they are perfect for those with sensitive eyes.
  • Waterproof: Another great thing about gel eyeliners is that they are waterproof, which means you can wear them when swimming or even in the rain without worrying about smudging your makeup.


  • Can be difficult to remove: Gel eyeliner can be a bit tricky to remove if you don’t have the right product. Make sure to use a good eye makeup remover or oil-based cleanser for the best results.
  • Dries quickly: Because gel eyeliner dries quickly, it can be difficult to correct mistakes. When applying your makeup make sure that you have a few extra cotton swabs on hand just in case!
  • Can cause irritation: Some people may find that gel eyeliners irritate their eyes so if you are prone to allergies or sensitive skin then we recommend trying out a different type of makeup product.
  • Can be expensive: Gel eyeliners can cost more than other types of eyeliner, so if you are on a budget then we recommend trying out another option such as liquid liner or pencils instead!

As you can see, there are both advantages and disadvantages to using gel eyeliner. Ultimately, it is up to you whether or not this type of liner is the right choice for you. If you are looking for a long-lasting product that doesn’t smudge then we highly recommend giving gel eyeliner a try!

Things to Consider When Choosing a Waterproof Gel Eyeliner

Waterproof gel eyeliners are a great choice for people who want a long-lasting eye makeup look. They can be worn all day and into the evening without smudging or fading. However, not all waterproof gel eyeliners are created equal. Here are some things to consider when choosing one:


The pigment in eyeliner is what gives it its color. A good waterproof gel eyeliner should have a high concentration of pigments, so it will last longer on your lids without fading or caking up.


The best way to make sure that you get the right amount of pigment is by using a brush with an angled tip for application and applying several coats until you’ve reached your desired intensity.

You can also try using a primer underneath to make sure that the eyeliner stays put all day long!

If you’re looking for an even more dramatic look, try applying your waterproof gel eyeliner overtop of eyeshadow or powder foundation (makeup artists call this “layering”). This will create a really intense color that will last all day long.

Pigmentation is also important when you’re buying a waterproof gel eyeliner because it determines how easy it is to remove at the end of the day. A high pigment will make for easier removal, while a low pigment makes removal difficult and may leave traces behind on your skin.

To check the pigment of a product, take a look at the swatch on the back of the packaging. The darker the line, the more pigment it contains.

One more way to test the pigment of a product is to try it out on your hand or arm before buying it. This way, you can see how it looks in natural light and whether or not it’s too bright or too dark for your skin tone.

If you have a lighter skin tone, stick with neutral shades like brown and black. These colors will look more natural on your lids!

If you’re looking for something bolder (like bright blue or purple), then go ahead and experiment with different brands until you find one that suits your needs. There are plenty out there—just be sure to check the pigmentation!

The best way to get rid of any leftover residue from your waterproof gel eyeliner is by using cleansing oil or balm. You can also try using a primer beneath it so that when you’re ready for removal at night, there won’t be any leftovers lingering on top of your skin!

A high-pigment product makes for easier removal, while low-pigment products leave traces behind on your skin and may require extra cleaning steps in order to remove them completely from your lids!

But be careful not to overdo it with the pigment—too much can make your eyes look muddy or dull.

If you want a bolder color, try using an eye shadow brush instead of the liner’s built-in applicator. This will give you more control when applying!

Waterproof Power

The next thing to look for in a gel liner is its waterproof ability. If you’re going to use an eyeliner that can offer long-lasting wear and won’t smudge throughout the day, it has to be waterproof!

However, not all waterproof eyeliners are created equal. Some are much better at resisting water than others. You need to make sure the liner you choose can hold up to whatever weather conditions you might encounter, whether it’s a hot and humid day or a rainy one.

The best waterproof gel eyeliners are those that have a long-lasting formula and won’t smudge, fade, or run no matter what.

To check if your eyeliner is waterproof, you can do a simple test:

Place a small amount of the product on your hand or arm and wait for it to dry. Then take some water from the tap – about an inch deep – and pour it onto the area where you applied liner.

Waterproof Power

Does anything happen? If not, then congratulations! You’ve found yourself a good waterproof eyeliner.

However, if the liner starts running or smudging, it’s not quite up to par and you might want to keep looking.

One more way to check if your eyeliner is waterproof is by applying a layer of it on top of another layer.

After you’ve applied the first coat and let it dry, apply the second one over top. If this doesn’t make any difference in terms of making your liner more resistant to water, then you should consider buying something else.

If you’re looking for a waterproof eyeliner that can stand up to even the toughest conditions, then we recommend trying out one of these top-rated picks!

We think they are some of the best in terms of quality and value, so check them out today!

If you are buying online, make sure you read reviews from real people who have actually tried out this product before making a purchase. If there are too few reviews for an item, then it may not be worth your time (and money).

In addition to reading customer feedback about how effective these products were in the past, also look for any complaints that might indicate potential issues you should be aware of.

Also, read the description and look for keywords like long-lasting, smudge-proof, waterproof, and non-transfer. If you can find an eyeliner that ticks all of these boxes, then you’ve definitely hit the jackpot!


There are a lot of different waterproof gel eyeliners on the market. Some are good and some are not so good. So, how do you know which one to choose?

One way to determine if a particular eyeliner is right for you is to read its compound. The compound is what makes up the product and can tell you a lot about it.

For instance, if the compound contains alcohol, it may not be suitable for sensitive eyes. Also, some compounds can cause irritation and are therefore not recommended for use around children or pets.


Another way is to look at its ingredients list. Some products contain harmful chemicals such as parabens, which can be absorbed through the skin.

Such ingredients as color additives and preservatives can also be absorbed through the skin, so these are not safe to use around children either.

It is best to avoid products that contain any type of fragrances or dyes as these may cause irritation if they come into contact with the eyes.

Alcohol-based eyeliners usually have a longer shelf life than those that are water-based.

Oil-based eyeliners are the most difficult to remove and can be very irritating to the eyes. However, they do have some advantages over the other types of eyeliners.

They stay on longer and are less likely to smudge or run when applied incorrectly. Also, they tend not to cause irritation if rubbed against the eye area as water-based formulations can.

The main disadvantage is that oil-based products will leave behind a greasy film, which can be very uncomfortable to wear.

Water-based eyeliners are much easier to remove than the other types of eye makeup and do not leave behind a greasy film. They also tend not to smudge or run when applied improperly. However, these products tend to be less effective at staying on longer because they dry out quickly after being applied.

The main disadvantage is that they can be difficult to remove and may irritate the eyes if rubbed against them too much or for prolonged periods of time.

Silicone derivatives help to create a waterproof barrier on the skin, making it difficult for any type of eye makeup to smudge or run. They are also very effective at keeping the area around the eyes hydrated, which can be beneficial if you have dry skin.

The downside is that they can often be more expensive than other types of eyeliners and may not last as long when applied correctly.

If you see wax listed as an ingredient, it is usually a wax-based product. Waxes are used in many types of cosmetics to give them a smooth application and prevent smudging or running.

They can also be very helpful for those who have dry skin since they create moisture barriers on the surface of the eyelid that can help keep eyes from becoming irritated during use.

If you see mineral oil listed as an ingredient, it usually means that a product contains paraffin or petrolatum which are petroleum-based products. These ingredients can help keep eyes from becoming dry by coating them with an invisible layer of moisture.

Olive oil is another ingredient that can be used to moisturize and nourish the skin around the eyes while keeping it looking healthy. It may also help reduce redness or swelling in some people who have sensitive eyes but should not be used on broken skin because it could cause irritation.

When it comes to ingredients, it is always best to go with those that you can recognize and understand. If you are not sure what an ingredient is or what it does, do some research before purchasing the product.

That way, you will know if it is something that your skin can tolerate and whether or not it contains any harmful chemicals that could cause irritation when applied directly to the eyes.

The best way to find out what ingredients are in a particular brand of eyeliner is by reading the label. It should list all active and inactive ingredients on its packaging so make sure you check this before making any purchases!

When choosing a waterproof gel eyeliner, it is important to consider both it’s compound and ingredients list to ensure that you are getting a product that is safe for you to use.


The quality of a product is important, especially when it comes to something that you put on your face. The best waterproof gel eyeliners are high-quality and will last all day without smudging or fading.

Remember the saying, “you get what you pay for?” This is definitely true when it comes to makeup. You don’t want to skimp on your eyeliner- invest in a good quality one and you won’t regret it.

We are talking about your eyes and your health, so it’s important to make sure that the brand you are buying from is reputable and trustworthy.

Quality depends on many factors, but in this case, it’s mostly about how well the product is made and if it contains any harmful chemicals.

The best waterproof gel eyeliners will not cause irritation to sensitive eyes nor do they contain any toxic ingredients such as parabens (which have been linked with cancer). This is something you definitely want to look for when purchasing a new eyeliner.


In addition to being made of high-quality ingredients, the best eyeliners are also very long-lasting. They won’t smudge or fade throughout the day, so you can go about your business without having to worry about constantly re-applying your liner.

So, if you’re looking for a high-quality, long-lasting eyeliner, then be sure to check out some of the best waterproof gel eyeliners on the market.

Comparison of Indicators for Choosing Waterproof Gel Eyeliners

When selecting a waterproof gel eyeliner, it’s important to consider various indicators to ensure you make the right choice. The following table compares key factors to help you in your decision-making process:

Indicator Description
Pigmentation The intensity and color payoff of the eyeliner.
Longevity The duration the eyeliner stays intact without smudging or fading.
Waterproof Rating The level of water resistance, ranging from water-resistant to fully waterproof.
Smudge-proof Whether the eyeliner is resistant to smudging or smearing.
Application The ease and precision of applying the eyeliner.
Drying Time The speed at which the eyeliner dries after application.
Price The cost of the eyeliner.
Cruelty-free Whether the eyeliner is produced without animal testing.

This table provides an overview of essential indicators to consider when choosing a waterproof gel eyeliner. Pigmentation and longevity determine the color payoff and how long the eyeliner will last without smudging or fading. The waterproof rating indicates the level of water resistance, while smudge-proof indicates whether the eyeliner is resistant to smearing. The ease of application and drying time are factors that affect the user experience. Price reflects the cost of the eyeliner, and cruelty-free indicates whether the product is produced without animal testing. Considering these indicators will help you find the perfect waterproof gel eyeliner that meets your preferences and needs.


Which eyeliner is better: gel or liquid?

Gel eyeliner is better because it is less likely to smudge than liquid liner. It also lasts longer on the eyes. However, if you are new to using eyeliner, I would recommend starting with liquid liner because it is a bit easier to control. Moreover, if your eyes are very sensitive, gel eyeliner might irritate them.

How to use a waterproof gel eyeliner?

First of all, you should clean and prep your skin with oil-free moisturizer or primer. Then apply the liner on the upper lash line starting from the inner corner moving outwardly until you reach the desired shape and thickness. For the lower lash line, start from the outer corner and move inward.

How long does gel eyeliner stay on?

Gel eyeliner can last up to 24 hours, depending on how well you apply it and the brand of eyeliner you are using. It is best to test out different brands until you find one that works best for your needs.

Can you use gel eyeliner on your waterline?

Some people do use gel eyeliner on their waterline, but I would not recommend it because it can be difficult to remove and can cause irritation. If you are looking for an eyeliner to use on your waterline, I would suggest a liquid liner instead.

What makes a gel eyeliner waterproof?

Gel eyeliners are formulated with ingredients that provide water-resistant properties, making them smudge-proof and long-lasting. These formulas often contain silicone, waxes, and film-forming agents that create a barrier against moisture, allowing the eyeliner to stay in place even in humid conditions or when exposed to water.

Are waterproof gel eyeliners suitable for sensitive eyes?

Yes, waterproof gel eyeliners can be suitable for sensitive eyes. However, it is important to check the product labels and choose those specifically labeled as hypoallergenic or suitable for sensitive eyes. These formulations are typically free from common irritants and are tested for potential allergens, reducing the risk of eye irritation or discomfort.

Can I use a waterproof gel eyeliner for tightlining?

Yes, waterproof gel eyeliners can be used for tightlining. Tightlining refers to applying eyeliner along the upper waterline, just beneath the lashes, to create a fuller lash appearance. Gel eyeliners, with their creamy and long-lasting formula, are well-suited for this technique. Make sure to choose a gel eyeliner that is safe for the waterline and avoid applying it too close to the inner corner of the eye to prevent potential irritation.

Do waterproof gel eyeliners smudge or fade throughout the day?

No, waterproof gel eyeliners are designed to resist smudging and fading throughout the day. Once the gel eyeliner sets, it forms a waterproof and smudge-proof film on the eyelids, ensuring that it stays in place for extended periods. However, factors such as excessive rubbing or oily eyelids can compromise the longevity of the eyeliner, so it’s best to avoid touching or rubbing your eyes.

How can I remove waterproof gel eyeliner effectively?

Removing waterproof gel eyeliner requires a gentle yet effective approach. You can use an oil-based makeup remover or a specifically formulated eye makeup remover. Soak a cotton pad or swab with the remover and gently press it against the eyeliner for a few seconds to allow the product to dissolve. Then, carefully swipe the pad or swab along the lash line to remove the eyeliner. Repeat if necessary, and make sure to rinse your eyes with water afterward to remove any residue.

Useful Video: Best Gel Eyeliner || Waterproof Gel Eyeliner

Final Thoughts

I’ve tried a lot of different eyeliners in my day. I like to think I have extensive experience with both liquid and gel eyeliners, so when it comes to talking about the best waterproof gel eyeliners on the market, you can trust that I know what I’m talking about.

Waterproof makeup is essential for those of us who like to swim, work out, or just generally be active. And when it comes to waterproof eyeliners, gel formulas reign supreme. They’re easy to apply, long-lasting, and don’t smudge or run – even in the most intense situations.

So if you need a new liner that will stay put no matter what, check out some of the best waterproof gel eyeliners on the market today.

I hope you were able to find a new waterproof gel eyeliner for your makeup bag! Which one is your favorite? Let us know in the comments section below.


  1. https://www.cyndispivey.com/2012/05/03/pros-and-cons-of-gel-eyeliner/