Success usually comes to those who are too busy to be looking for it.Henry David Thoreau

Why Does My Waterproof Mascara Smudge?

Why Does My Waterproof Mascara Smudge?

Are you tired of spending your hard-earned money on waterproof mascara, only for it to betray you and smudge at the most inconvenient times? The struggle is real, but fear not, because we’re here to solve the mystery! In this comprehensive guide, we will delve into the reasons behind why your waterproof mascara smudges and provide you with the ultimate solutions to make it work for you. Whether you’re a makeup enthusiast or just tired of dealing with panda eyes, we’ve got you covered. Get ready to say goodbye to smudged mascara and hello to flawless, smudge-free lashes that will withstand anything life throws at them!

Reasons for Mascara Smudging

There are several reasons why your waterproof mascara may smudge. Firstly, if you’re not removing it properly with an oil-based cleanser, the oils can build up on your lashes and cause it to run. Furthermore, if you don’t apply enough coats of mascara or the formula is too old, it’s also prone to running down your face. Even the type of mascara and its brush can have an effect on how likely it is to smudge. [1]

Method to Prevent Smudging

If you want to minimize the chances of your waterproof mascara smudging, there are a few steps you can take to make sure that it stays in place.

First, make sure you apply one thin layer of waterproof mascara and avoid piling too much on, as this can cause it to become clumpy and messy. Avoid applying multiple coats, as this will leave your eyelashes heavy and more likely to smudge.

Next, be sure to apply a top coat of clear mascara to seal in the waterproof layer and help keep it from smudging. This will also help add a glossy finish that can further enhance the look of your lashes.

Finally, always make sure you remove your makeup before going to bed at night. This will help keep your waterproof mascara from smudging onto your face or pillow while you sleep.

These methods should help prevent smudging of waterproof mascara and promote long lasting wear. With the right application, removal techniques, and a top coat of clear mascara, you can experience beautiful lashes that stay in place all day.

Method to Prevent Smudging

Which Mascaras Are Actually Smudge-proof?

When you’re shopping for mascara, it’s important to check the label. Not all mascaras labeled “waterproof” are actually smudge-proof. Look for formulas that contain polymers or waxes that help them stay put throughout the day. Some of our favorite waterproof mascaras include:

  • L’Oreal Voluminous Waterproof Mascara
  • Maybelline Great Lash Waterproof Mascara
  • Covergirl Lash Blast Volume Waterproof Mascara
  • Neutrogena Healthy Volume Waterproof Mascara

These options are great for keeping your lashes looking full and voluminous, even in the rain! Additionally, they won’t smudge or flake, ensuring a long-lasting look.

Tubing Mascara

Tubing mascaras are on the rise because of their long-lasting wear and smudge-resistant qualities. Tubing mascara is made up of polymer ‘tubes’ that form around each lash while it dries. This creates a waterproof, smudge-proof coating that can last all day – no matter how hot and humid it gets.

Tubing mascaras don’t need to be reapplied or touched up throughout the day. They are generally quite easy to remove with just warm water and a gentle cleanser. Unlike traditional mascaras, none of the product is actually left on your lashes, so you don’t have to worry about that pesky raccoon eye look.

Tubing mascaras can be a great option for those who struggle with their waterproof mascara smudging. They’re also great for those who don’t want to have to reapply their mascara throughout the day. [2]

So if you’ve tried every waterproof mascara out there and are still struggling with smudging, it might be time to give tubing mascaras a try!

Tubing Mascara

Cake Mascara

Cake mascara is a type of waterproof mascara that uses cake-like ingredients and synthetic waxes to create a clump-free, smudge proof formula. Unlike regular mascaras, cake mascara does not require the use of brushes or spoolies – instead it should be applied with an applicator wand directly onto the lashes. The creamy texture helps prevent clumping and flaking, while the waxes help to keep your mascara in place all day.

Cake mascara is not as long-lasting as other waterproof mascaras, but it does provide a lightweight and natural look. It can be difficult to remove without any specialized makeup remover, so if you’re looking for an easy way to take off your makeup, this might not be the best option for you. However, it does provide a great way to achieve a long-lasting look without weighing down your lashes.

Cake mascara is a great choice for those with sensitive eyes or contact lens wearers as it is less likely to cause irritation than regular mascaras. It can also be a great option for those who want to create a natural look without the hassle of applying regular mascara. [3]

Overall, cake mascara is an excellent choice if you want to achieve a long-lasting and clump-free look without having to use extra brushes or spoolies. Make sure you remove it with specialized makeup remover and you should have no problem achieving beautiful, smudge-proof lashes! With the right technique and products, you can easily avoid the common issue of waterproof mascara smudging.

Cake Mascara

How to Keep Mascara From Smudging?

There are a few key things to keep in mind if you want your waterproof mascara to stay put. First and foremost, it’s important to ensure that you are applying your mascara correctly. Use the wand provided with the product or a clean spoolie brush (a small disposable brush) to comb through your lashes and remove any clumps of excess product. Make sure to start at the root of your lashes and lightly wiggle the wand as you move it up towards the tips, this will ensure that all of your lashes are evenly coated with the product.

Once you’re finished applying your mascara it’s important to let it dry before moving on to other makeup steps. If you try to move on too quickly, the product can smudge or transfer to other parts of your face. Additionally, it’s important to ensure that you are using the right product for your needs. If you have oily eyelids, a waterproof formula may not be enough and you should consider an oil-free formula instead.

If your mascara is still smudging despite all of your precautionary steps, your best bet is to start with a fresh tube. Old mascara can become clumpy and dry out, so it’s best to replace the product as soon as you notice that it’s not performing as expected. Additionally, if you live in a warm or humid climate you may want to consider investing in a thermal-resistant mascara that can withstand high temperatures.

Finally, when using waterproof formulas it’s important to make sure you are removing your makeup properly at the end of the day. Many people find that a dedicated eye makeup remover works best for waterproof mascaras, as it will help dissolve and easily remove all traces of the product without tugging or irritating the skin around the eyes. [4]

How to Keep Mascara From Smudging?

Can Concealers Cover Up Mascara Smudges?

It’s not a good idea to rely on concealer alone to cover mascara smudges, as this will only result in a heavy and cakey makeup look. Concealer can be used as part of your routine for camouflaging any imperfections or dark circles that may be present beneath the eyes before applying your mascara, but it’s not recommended to use it as a fix-all solution for mascara smudges.

A better solution is to opt for a primer or setting powder to help lock in your mascara and keep it from smudging. Primers provide an additional layer between skin and makeup, creating a barrier that ensures makeup stays put all day long without transferring onto clothes or other surfaces. Setting powders also help set your makeup in place and are typically applied after using a primer. When used correctly, this powerful combination of products can help safeguard your mascara against any unwanted smudges throughout the day.

Finally, it’s important to make sure you’re properly removing all traces of makeup before going to bed each night. Makeup removers that are specifically designed for waterproof formulas can be particularly helpful here. Choosing the right remover can make all the difference when it comes to preventing smudging and preserving the longevity of your waterproof mascara. [5]

Ultimately, with a little extra care and attention you can ensure your mascara stays put – no matter what activities come your way!

Can Concealers Cover Up Mascara Smudges?

Is Putting Clear Brow Gel on Eyelashes a Good Idea?

If you’ve ever wondered if it’s a good idea to put clear brow gel on your eyelashes, the answer is this: it depends. While some people may find that applying a light coating of clear brow gel helps hold their mascara in place, it can also be an irritating and drying experience for others.

For those who want to use a product to help their mascara stay in place, there are better alternatives. Waterproof mascara is formulated specifically to resist smudging and fading, so it’s the ideal choice for people who want all-day wear. Additionally, using a primer or setting spray underneath your mascara further increases its longevity and helps prevent smudges.

Another helpful tip is to keep the wand as clean as possible. Bacteria and makeup can build up on the brush over time, which can cause smudging. If you wear mascara every day, it’s a good idea to replace it every few weeks.

Finally, when applying your mascara, be sure to keep your eyelid closed while swiping the wand back and forth. This will help to minimize clumping and prevent smudging. [6]

Of course, if none of these methods work for you, then using a thin coat of clear brow gel might be the right choice for your needs. Just be sure to use it sparingly – a little goes a long way.

No matter which approach you decide is best for you, giving your mascara the TLC it needs can help ensure that your look stays beautiful and smudge-free!

Is Putting Clear Brow Gel on Eyelashes a Good Idea?

How to Make Mascara Last Longer?

Now that you know why w-proof mascara can smudge, it’s time to put that knowledge into action. Here are a few tips on how to make your mascara last longer and avoid the dreaded raccoon eyes:

  • Start with clean lashes. Be sure to remove all old makeup from your lashes as well as oil and dirt build-up. This will help the mascara adhere better and give you a more even coat.
  • Don’t pump your wand in and out of the tube. When you pump, you are introducing air into the tube which can dry out your product faster. Instead, twist the wand into the tube to get enough product without overdoing it.
  • Start with a few coats of lengthening mascara. Applying a coat or two of a lengthening formula before applying your w-proof mascara can help it stay put longer.
  • Use an oil-based makeup remover. Oil-based removers are best at breaking down waterproof formulas without scrubbing away your delicate lashes.

With the right tools and techniques in hand, you can kiss those raccoon eyes goodbye.

Bonus Tips to Stop Mascara From Smudging

Once you have figured out the root of your smudging problem, there are some bonus tips that can help keep your mascara from smudging at all.

  • Start with clean lashes! No matter what you do, if your lashes aren’t clean before application, it’s pretty much just a waste of time and product.
  • Curl your lashes! A good curl in the lashes helps keep mascara from smudging down and out.
  • Don’t overdo it with product layers! Mascara is meant to be built up, but if you pile on too much, it’s likely to start running. Start with just one coat and build up as needed.
  • Use a setting powder! Giving your lashes a light dusting of setting powder can help keep the mascara in place all day long.
  • Try using an eyelash primer! This is great for adding added volume before mascara application, but it also gives extra staying power to any formula you choose.
  • Don’t forget to remove it! Use a gentle remover and rinse with lukewarm water to keep your lashes healthy.

Whether you have oily skin, sensitive eyes, or simply don’t want to reapply, these tips are sure to help you solve the mystery of why my w-proof mascara smudges. With a bit of experimentation and testing, you’ll be able to find the best formula and application method for your needs.

And don’t forget – if you want a long-wearing look with absolutely no smudging, try out our Waterproof Volume Mascara! It offers up to 24 hours of wear and unparalleled smudge resistance, so you can go about your day without worrying.


How Do You Set Mascara So It Doesn’t Smudge?

The key to setting mascara so it doesn’t smudge is to apply the right amount at the right time. Use a light coat of non-waterproof mascara first, wait for it to dry, then layer on waterproof mascara if desired. Be sure to start with clean and dry lashes, as any dirt or oil present can cause smudging. If you find your mascara smudges, you may need to switch brands or formulations. Waterproof mascaras generally last longer than non-waterproof varieties, but they do require more effort to remove. Use a gentle remover and natural oils (like coconut oil) to break down the formula without tugging at delicate lashes.

Is It Bad to Wear Waterproof Mascara Every Day?

The short answer is, no. But like anything else, it’s best to take a balanced approach. Some people find that wearing waterproof mascara every day can cause their lashes to become brittle and dry out over time, resulting in lash breakage or irritation. For these people, alternating between regular and waterproof mascaras may be the better option. [7]

Does Waterproof Mascara Smudge When You Cry?

The million dollar question. The answer is a bit complicated. Waterproof mascara is designed to stay put, no matter what you do or how many tears are shed. But that doesn’t mean it’s completely immune to smudging – there are certain conditions in which even the most reliable waterproof mascara can start to slide off your lashes.

It might surprise you to know that waterproof mascara smudging is more likely to occur when your eyes are dry, rather than when they’re producing tears. When the formula of a waterproof mascara meets air-dried skin, it can cause clumps and flaking. To prevent this from happening, make sure you always apply a thin layer of moisturizer on your eyelids before you apply your mascara.

Another reason for smudging is if you use too much product. When it comes to waterproof mascaras, less is more. Applying multiple coats of the same formula might look good at first, but in a matter of minutes it will start to flake off and create an unsightly mess around your eyes. To ensure a clump-free finish, apply just one coat of mascara and let it dry for a few seconds before going in with another layer. [8]

Finally, the last common cause of smudging is not removing your waterproof mascara properly. Just like regular mascara, waterproof formulas need to be removed with an oil-based cleanser or makeup remover. When these products are used, the waterproof formula will slowly start to break down and can be wiped away with a cotton pad.

Which Mascara is Better Waterproof or Washable?

Waterproof mascaras tend to be a bit more expensive than washable options, and they don’t always provide as thick of an effect. If you are looking for both waterproof protection and fullness, then you should opt for a water-resistant mascara. This type of formula is designed to give your lashes a thicker look while still offering the protection that comes with a waterproof product.

However, keep in mind that no matter the type of mascara you choose, both are prone to smudging if not applied correctly. Applying too much or too little can result in mascara transferring onto your lids and other areas around your eye area. To ensure this doesn’t happen, it’s important to apply your mascara with a light hand. And don’t forget to always start at the base of your lashes and work your way up for maximum volume and length.

If you want to take extra measures, create a waterproof barrier around your eyes before applying mascara. You can do this by using an eye primer or even just some face powder around your eyes. This will help keep the mascara in place and reduce the risk of it smudging.

Whatever type of mascara you decide to use, always make sure to remove it at night with an oil-based cleanser or micellar water. This will ensure that your lashes look their best for as long as possible without any worrying smudges!

Is Waterproof Mascara Worse for Your Eyelashes?

It’s a common misconception that waterproof mascaras are harsher on your eyelashes than other formulas. This is because waterproof mascara formulas adhere to the lashes more strongly, which can make it harder to remove. However, this doesn’t mean that waterproof mascaras are worse for your eyelashes. In fact, most of today’s waterproof mascaras have been formulated so that they don’t dry out your lashes, and they can actually be gentler than non-waterproof formulas. The key is to always use a gentle eye makeup remover to take off your waterproof mascara, as this will ensure that you’re not tugging or pulling on your delicate eyelashes. [9]

Useful Video: BEAUTY HACK! How To: Prevent Mascara from SMUDGING! Carli Bybel


Waterproof mascara is designed to stay put all day, but sometimes it still smudges. This can be caused by a variety of factors such as poor application, inadequate product selection, or even environmental conditions. By taking the time to understand why your waterproof mascara might not work for you and making sure that you’re using the right products with the proper techniques, you can enjoy the long-lasting wear waterproof mascara is meant to provide. Have fun out there!


  1. https://hudabeauty.com/us/en_US/blog-mascara-smudging-80142.html
  2. https://www.cosmopolitan.com/uk/beauty-hair/makeup/g43686678/tubing-mascara/
  3. https://www.vitry.com/en/produit/cake-mascara/
  4. https://www.realsimple.com/beauty-fashion/makeup/eyes/how-to-prevent-mascara-from-smudging
  5. https://www.rmsbeauty.com/blogs/news/simple-tricks-to-prevent-mascara-from-smudging
  6. https://cleanbeautycoach.com/can-you-use-eyebrow-gel-on-your-lashes/
  7. https://stylecaster.com/beauty/makeup/429569/weird-facts-about-mascara/
  8. https://www.vanityfair.com/style/photos/2019/08/best-waterproof-and-cry-proof-mascaras
  9. https://www.makeup.com/en-ca/product-and-reviews/mascara/waterproof-mascara-guide